1. STRUCTURE OF THE DISSERTATION
2. RULES FOR FORMATTING THE DISSERTATION
3. DISSERTATION DEFENSE PROCEDURE
1. STRUCTURE OF THE DISSERTATION
The main part of the dissertation should make up at least 70% of its total volume. Based on the logical structure of the presentation, it is divided into chapters and paragraphs. A candidate's dissertation may have 3 or 4 chapters, while a doctoral work may have 4 or more. Each chapter consists of 2 or more paragraphs. It is advisable for the chapters to be roughly equal in volume.
The logical structure of a dissertation does not become obvious right away. To make it fully clear, you need to mentally design it as a logical whole, built as a detailed proof of the propositions put forward for defense. First, such a "layout" should be worked out in the form of an outline, giving each paragraph a proper title and the right place. The division of the work into chapters and paragraphs must serve the logic of covering the topic. Therefore, on the one hand, the outline should not include structural units that go beyond the topic or are only indirectly related to it, and on the other hand, the items must cover the topic fully. The dissertation outline is the logical skeleton of the presentation, in which everything must be in its place.
The chapters of a dissertation are the main structural units of the text. The title of each should be worded so that, in terms of content, it is not broader than or equal to the topic, because a chapter is only one aspect of the topic and its title must reflect this subordination.
After the outline has been drawn up, you can begin writing a draft of the text. When writing a large work, it is better to write it in smaller parts, each of which must fit the overall intellectual plot of the dissertation.
Of course, there is no single standard for the composition of a dissertation. Each researcher chooses the order in which to organize the scientific material. Nevertheless, certain general requirements have been developed for the compositional structure of a dissertation. The dissertation must contain the following elements:
- Title page
- Table of contents
- Introduction
- Chapters of the main part
- Conclusion
- Bibliography
- Appendix
- Auxiliary indexes
The title page (see Appendix 1) is the first page of the dissertation and is filled in according to strictly established rules.
The full name of the educational institution or scientific organization where the research was carried out is shown in the top field. The top field with this text is separated by a line from the rest of the title page.
Next, the full name of the dissertation author is given (in the nominative case).
In the center, the title of the dissertation is given, without the word "topic" and without quotation marks.
After the title of the dissertation, the code from the nomenclature of specialties and the academic degree being sought are placed.
Then, closer to the right edge of the title page, the full name, academic degree and position of the scientific supervisor (consultant) are given.
In the bottom field, the place (city) where the dissertation was done and the year it was written are given (the word "year" is not written).
After the title page comes the table of contents (Appendix 2), which lists all the chapters, paragraphs and headings of the dissertation with the numbers of the pages on which they begin. The headings in the table of contents must repeat the headings in the text fully and exactly. They may not be shortened or altered in contradiction to the headings in the text.
Headings of the same level of subdivision are placed one after another. The heading of each next level is placed 3-5 characters to the right of the heading of the previous level. Each heading begins with a capital letter and no period is put at the end. The last word of each heading is joined to the page number with a row of dots.
The introduction is the most important part of the dissertation (Appendix 3), because it contains all the fundamental points. These are the relevance of the chosen topic, the aim, the content, the object and subject of the research, the research method, the theoretical and practical significance, etc.
Everything has already been said above about the relevance of the topic. From the point of view of the compositional structure of the dissertation, the justification of the topic's relevance should take up no more than 1-2 pages of the introduction and should explain why it is necessary to turn to this topic now, what its scientific and practical necessity is, and what the current state of ideas about the subject of research is.
After the justification of relevance, the degree to which the problem has been scientifically studied should be considered. Here one should speak of how scholars of our country and foreign scholars, in the past and at present, have dealt with this problem from different perspectives, about insufficiently covered aspects, and about literature that treats the matter incorrectly. The turn to this particular topic can be justified by the insufficient coverage in foreign literature of material relating to our Motherland.
Here you can demonstrate that you understand the topic well, can work with texts, are familiar with the bibliography, and are therefore able to correctly assess the contribution of earlier scholars to covering this topic. You must also be able to objectively assess your own contribution to covering the topic. Sometimes researchers conclude that nobody has addressed the topic before them. If you have a similar thought, do not rush to speak of it in the introduction. Analyze the existing literature thoroughly, consult your scientific adviser, and only then can you decide whether to make such a sweeping claim.
After considering the degree to which the problem has been studied scientifically, you can move on to the logical justification of your personal contribution to the study of this problem. Here the aim and tasks of the dissertation research, its strategy and tactics are set out. It should be kept in mind that the list of tasks determines the internal logic and outline of the text of the work. Then the object and subject of the research are formulated. The object of scientific research is a chosen element of reality that has its own boundaries and autonomy and stands apart from its environment. The object gives rise to a problem situation and is chosen for studying it. The subject of scientific research is the logical statement of the object, chosen by the researcher for study and review.
The object and subject of scientific research, as categories of the scientific process, are connected with each other through their general and particular aspects.
Within the object, a part that serves as the subject of research stands out. The dissertation author's attention is directed to it; it is the subject of research that defines the topic of the dissertation and is shown on the title page as its title.
The skill of defining the subject of research depends on how close the researcher has come, first, to the sphere of the current dynamic state of the object, and second, to the area of links and elements that influence the organizational system of the object.
Briefly describing the structural stages of the presentation and justifying the logic of its construction is not mandatory, but it is advisable.
The main part of the work should make up 70% of the total volume and match the dissertation outline in structure. Here the course of your research is set out in detail and its intermediate results are substantiated. Proof of the facts, consistency, and the absence of superfluous, unnecessary material are among the strict requirements for the main part.
The concluding part of the dissertation must consist of conclusions and recommendations on the results of the whole work (Appendix 4). Although this part is the smallest in volume, it is of special importance, because it is precisely here that you present the final results of your scientific work to the scientific community in a completed, logically perfect form. The conclusion is not merely the sum of the results achieved but also a kind of synthesis, a separate and summary outcome of your work. In the conclusion, you should relate the results obtained to the aim and tasks defined in the introduction, bring the conclusions together and assess the success of your work. Sometimes this part can be built as a list of conclusions, divided into items, with a separate conclusion substantiated in each. If the work has practical significance along with theoretical results, this should also be mentioned in the conclusion. In addition, on the basis of the results of the work, the prospects for further research can be indicated, new tasks set, and ways of developing new ideas pointed out.
After the conclusion comes the bibliography (Appendix 5). This is a list of the literary sources used by the author on the topic. Every source included in such a list must be reflected in the dissertation manuscript. When referring to any facts, it must be shown where the material was taken from. Sources that have no references and were not used in the dissertation do not need to be included in the list.
Auxiliary or additional materials are placed in the appendix.
In terms of content, appendices are varied:
- intermediate mathematical proofs, formulas, calculations;
- statistical data and methods of processing them;
- results of specific experiments;
- primary materials;
- auxiliary nomograms and tables;
- descriptions of the apparatus and equipment used in experiments, measurements and tests;
- the methodology of the program of second-level algorithms and problems solved on computers, developed in the course of the dissertation research;
- auxiliary illustrations;
- extended commentary;
- certificates of use of the results of the dissertation work (Appendix 14).
Appendices are placed at the end of the dissertation. Each appendix must begin on a new page with the word "Appendix" in the upper right corner and have its own heading.
If the dissertation has more than 1 appendix, they are numbered with Arabic numerals (the № sign is not used), for example "Appendix 1"; the numbering of the pages on which the appendices are given continues the page numbering of the main text.
The connection of the main text with the appendices is established by references with the word "see". For example: "see Appendix 1".
As an example, let us consider the structure of a dissertation consisting of the following parts:
- Table of contents
- Introduction
- Chapter one
- Chapter two
- Chapter three
- Chapter four
- Conclusion
A dissertation for the defense of an academic degree usually consists of a title page, a table of contents, main notations and abbreviations, an introduction, the main text (3-5 chapters, with clear conclusions given for each chapter), a general conclusion on the work, a list of references used (100-170 items for a candidate's dissertation) and an appendix.
In the introduction (7-10 pages) the researcher briefly defines the object of research, states the relevance of the problem, its current state and the existing difficulties in solving it, sets out the essence of the scientific task posed or of the new developments, the aim, directions and methods of their own research and the content by chapters, and expresses gratitude to the scientific supervisor, adviser and colleagues. This is a short annotation that covers the degree to which the problem has been worked out; the novelty introduced by the author in the subject of research and the main propositions are set out here. Not only results but also new ideas, views and ways of implementing them are presented. Thus, the introduction justifies the relevance of the dissertation topic, states the aim, defines the tasks and gives a general idea of the work.
It should be noted that the researcher is advised to carefully rewrite the introduction several times at different stages of the work. After all, this is the section that inquisitive readers read first, and it is at this point that the first, hard-to-change impression of the work and its author is formed.
The first chapter includes a detailed review of known studies, a patent analysis, and materials setting out what is needed to solve the tasks that have been set.
The review of known studies gives an outline of the main and turning-point stages in the development of scientific thought on the question being addressed. The systematization of known studies carried out by the dissertation author adorns the chapter and the whole work, strengthening the general impression of the work's integrity. Covering the work of predecessors briefly and critically, the author should dwell on questions that remain uncovered, define their own place in solving the problem, and clarify and formulate the tasks of the dissertation research. The first chapter of a candidate's dissertation is usually 20-25 pages.
In the next section, the author's own research is set out in full, with special attention given to the novelty they have introduced in working out the problem. This novelty must be substantiated by theoretical propositions and agree with the known propositions of theory and practice.
The whole order of presentation of the dissertation must be subordinated to the main idea defended by the author.
The second chapter may be devoted to the theoretical justification of the solution of the task and to the methodology of its solution. The task of the chapter is to give the theory of the question in general form. In a candidate's dissertation, new theoretical principles for solving the task are rarely given. In the existing mathematical apparatus it is most often possible to find the necessary theoretical platform, but in its initial form it remains only a preparatory product for further reasoning. Further reasoning usually consists in establishing matching coefficients, new terms in the equations, additional equations reflecting the physics of the process being analyzed, and newly found factors.
When using matching coefficients, attention must be paid to accuracy. In the simplest case these are empirical coefficients that reconcile the results of theory and experiment. However, one can go further and find a theoretical basis for the matching coefficient itself. Perhaps they are not static but dynamic and in turn depend on other parameters. Using a matching coefficient as an addition to the results of experiment and theory is a methodological error. The ideal theory is a solution obtained with modern computer tools. However, it must be remembered that a numerical solution is always a particular solution. At the same time, an analytical solution makes it possible to consider more solutions and to analyze the process qualitatively. One should not think that one solution of a problem is better than another. Any theoretical generalization capable of explaining and predicting the development of a process has a right to exist. The volume of the second chapter is 35-40 pages.
The third chapter usually includes the experimental justification of the solution of the task, a description of the methods of experimental research, and the accuracy and analysis of experimental and theoretical results. The task of the experimental chapter is to make concrete the generalized theoretical solution of the problem, present experimental coefficients, and give experimental points that test the theory. Here one can describe new installations, check their operation, and set out new methods and technology for conducting experimental research. The volume of the 3rd chapter is 30-35 pages.
The fourth chapter may include specific solutions, installations, graphs, dependencies, secondary models, and an assessment of how well theoretical ideas match experimental data for a specific model. A separate paragraph can be devoted to discussing and assessing the results of the dissertation work. The assessment of the results of the work must be both qualitative and quantitative. Comparison with known solutions should be carried out in all aspects, including efficiency. 20-25 pages are allotted to the chapter.
The conclusion presents the results of the work. The main thoughts on the results of the research are formulated, and information is given about approbation, about the coverage of the main content of the dissertation in scientific publications, about its results, and about the protection of the solutions by patents. The organizations where the dissertation results are applied and can be applied are indicated. Up to eight pages are allotted to this section.
In the appendix to the dissertation additional materials of a reference nature are placed. These can be tables, graphs, programs, solutions of problems on computers, and formulas.
2. RULES FOR FORMATTING DISSERTATIONS
These Rules were developed on the basis of the Regulations "On the Higher Attestation Commission under the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan", approved by Resolution No. 421 of the Cabinet of Ministers of the Republic of Uzbekistan of 9 September 1992, and the "Regulations on the procedure for awarding academic degrees", approved by Resolution No. 34/2 of the Presidium of the HAC of the Republic of Uzbekistan of 25 January 1996 and registered at the Ministry of Justice of the Republic of Uzbekistan on 10 July 1996 under number 261.
I. Criteria for dissertations and author's abstracts
1. A dissertation submitted for the academic degree of Doctor of Sciences must be a scientific work in which, on the basis of research carried out by the author and developments created by them, a scientific problem of major national-economic, socio-cultural or socio-political importance has been solved, or a set of theoretical propositions has been developed that can be regarded as a major achievement in developing a promising direction of the relevant field of science, or scientifically grounded technical, economic or technological solutions have been set out, the introduction of which makes a significant contribution to the development of science and technology.
2. A dissertation submitted for the academic degree of Candidate of Sciences must be a scientific work in which a question of great importance for the relevant field of science is solved in a new way, or the author's scientifically grounded technical, economic or technological recommendations that ensure the solution of important practical issues are set out.
3. The dissertation must be written personally, contain a set of new scientific results and propositions presented by the author for public discussion at an open defense, have internal unity in substance and reflect the author's personal contribution to science.
The new solutions obtained by the author must be seriously substantiated and critically assessed in comparison with other known solutions.
4. A dissertation of practical significance must give information on the solution of a specific problem and on the practical use of the scientific results achieved by the author, and a dissertation of theoretical significance must give recommendations on the use of the scientific conclusions.
5. A dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Sciences in the form of a scientific report is prepared on the basis of the body of the applicant's previously published scientific and experimental design works that are widely known to specialists in this field of science and are of great importance for science and practice, and consists of a brief generalized account of the results of the research and developments carried out by the author. The conclusion on the significance of the scientific work and on the advisability of defending a doctoral dissertation in the form of a scientific report is given by the organization in which the applicant's main research was conducted and developments were carried out.
Permission to defend a doctoral dissertation in the form of a scientific report is given by the Higher Attestation Commission (hereinafter — HAC) on the basis of an application from the specialized council.
A dissertation in the form of a scientific report includes a cover (front and back) and a text part of the established form (see Appendix 7).
6. The main scientific results of the dissertation must be published in scientific publications.
The main scientific results of a doctoral dissertation must be published in leading peer-reviewed scientific journals and scientific publications.
The total number of the dissertation author's scientific works must be at least 20. Among the applicant's scientific works there must be at least ten articles published after the defense of the candidate's dissertation in periodical scientific journals from the list of journals approved by the Presidium of the HAC. For doctoral dissertations in the social sciences, humanities and economics a monograph on the results of the dissertation must have been published, and in the other fields of science, as well as in pedagogy, psychology, philosophy and economics, at least two articles must have been published in authoritative scientific journals of foreign countries where this field of science is highly developed.
The main scientific results of a candidate's dissertation must be published in printed scientific publications. The total number of the dissertation author's scientific works must be at least five. Among the applicant's works there must be at least two articles published in periodical scientific journals from the list of journals approved by the Presidium of the HAC.
The applicant's published scientific works must reflect the main results of the dissertation being defended.
Works that have been submitted for publication but not yet published may not be cited in the dissertation and in the author's abstracts of dissertations.
7. After the announcement of the defense of the dissertation is posted on the HAC web page, the author's abstract of the dissertation is published, as a manuscript, with the permission of the specialized council. A doctoral dissertation in the form of a scientific report is distributed as an author's abstract.
8. The author's abstract must set out the main ideas and conclusions of the dissertation and indicate the author's contribution to the research conducted, the degree of novelty of the research results and their practical significance.
Only one scientific adviser is indicated on the title page of a doctoral dissertation and on the back of the cover of the author's abstract.
Only one scientific supervisor is indicated on the title page of a candidate's dissertation and on the back of the cover of the author's abstract.
Where necessary, with the permission of the HAC, a second scientific supervisor or adviser may be indicated on the title page of the dissertation and on the back of the cover of the author's abstract. Dissertations done at the junction of specialties are an exception.
9. The dissertation and the author's abstract may be written in one of the languages: Uzbek, Russian or English. At the end of the author's abstract there must be a short summary in Uzbek, Russian and English.
The summary must not exceed one page for a doctoral dissertation and half a page for a candidate's dissertation.
10. The author's abstract of the dissertation is printed at a printing house or on copying equipment in the number of copies determined by the specialized council.
II. Rules for formatting the dissertation
11. A dissertation usually consists of a table of contents, an introduction, a main part (sections of the dissertation), conclusions, a list of references and an appendix, and is formatted in the established manner.
The title page is formatted according to the model approved by the HAC (see Appendix 2).
The title of the dissertation must be exact and brief (as a rule, no more than 10 words).
After approval by the scientific council, the topic of the dissertation must be published in the journal "HAC Bulletin".
12. The table of contents must list the names of all existing sections (chapters), paragraphs (parts) and items, as well as the numbers of the pages on which they begin.
13. The list of conventional notations, units, symbols and terms must include an explication (explanation) of the letter designations and symbols that occur most frequently in the formulas.
Terms and designations must be uniform throughout the dissertation. If the author introduces a new term, they must explain it at its first use. Throughout the dissertation the unit of measurement of each parameter must always be the same.
14. The introduction (preface) should make easier the understanding that forms in the course of reading the work. Therefore, the object and subject of the scientific research should be stated here clearly and concisely, and the relevance of carrying out this research should be justified.
A dissertation must be distinguished by novelty. Therefore, the preface must set out, in the form of a short annotation, the novelty introduced by the author in solving the problem (for a candidate's dissertation) or in the field of science (for a doctoral dissertation).
In addition, the introduction gives the aim of the work, its theoretical significance, its practical value, the research methods, the main propositions that the author puts forward for defense, information on the approbation of the work and the published works, and the structure of the dissertation.
15. A dissertation must have at least three sections. The sections set out the main content of the work. As a rule, in the first section of the dissertation the applicant must give a brief assessment of the current state of the question under study within the scientific and technical problem (for candidate's works) and a characterization of the current state of the field of science (for doctoral dissertations). This assessment and characterization may also be given in the introduction of the dissertation.
In addition, the problem must be set out here, it must be shown that the results defined by the aim of the research do not exist in this field of science, and the research tasks must be posed. The subsequent sections of the main part of the dissertation are devoted to solving the questions posed in the first section.
16. The dissertation must meet the following requirements imposed on any scientific work:
- logical consistency that gives the reader a clear idea, in the presentation of the material, of the mutual connection of the sections of the dissertation and, within sections, of the connection of paragraphs and items;
- reliability of the arguments;
- accuracy and brevity of the thought expressed, excluding any other interpretation;
- a clear statement of the results of solving the particular question (questions) in each section of the research.
To meet the last requirement, the applicant must give conclusions on the section in the form of a paragraph at the end of the sections of the dissertation.
17. The conclusion must consist of a brief generalized statement of the results of the entire dissertation research, as well as recommendations on the use and implementation of the results obtained.
18. It is recommended to format the list of literature used on the dissertation topic in accordance with Appendix 3.
The order in which the list is built is determined by the author. Widely used ways of arranging materials in a list of references are alphabetical, systematic, and in the order of references in the text.
A reference to literature in the text is given in the form [1], [2], [3]…
For the dissertation topic, it is recommended to use mainly literature published within the last 10-15 years.
19. The appendices may be bound together with the main text of the dissertation in one book or issued as a separate book. The appendices include various auxiliary materials that supplement and illustrate the text of the dissertation:
- intermediate mathematical proofs, formulas, calculations;
- statistical data and methods of processing them;
- results of specific experiments;
- source materials;
- auxiliary nomograms and tables;
- descriptions of the apparatus and equipment used in experiments, measurements and tests;
- auxiliary algorithms and programs and methods for solving problems on computers, developed in the course of the dissertation research;
- illustrations (images) of an auxiliary nature;
- detailed explanations;
- copies of inventor's certificates and patents for discoveries and inventions;
- certificates of implementation of the results of the dissertation work, and others.
The order of the appendices must correspond to the order in which they are referred to in the dissertation and ensure ease of use.
20. The text of the dissertation must be typed on a computer in WORD font size 14 with 1.5 line spacing on one side of standard white A4 paper.
The text of a doctoral dissertation must not exceed 250 pages, and of a candidate's dissertation 120 pages. The volume of a dissertation in the social sciences and humanities may be increased by no more than 30 percent. Appendices are not included in the specified volume.
On the pages of the dissertation a margin of 30 mm must be left on the left, 25 mm at the top, 15 mm on the right and 25 mm at the bottom.
21. All pages of the dissertation are numbered in order from the title page to the last page. The first page is considered the title page and no number is put on it; the next page is marked with the number "2", and so on. The serial number is placed in the middle of the top of the page.
Each section of the dissertation begins on a new page. This rule also applies to the other main structural parts of the work: the introduction, the conclusions, the list of references used, and the appendices.
22. The names of sections are written in capital letters. Headings within a section are written from the paragraph indent in lowercase letters. Word hyphenation is not allowed in headings. No period is put at the end of a heading. It is recommended to leave 3-4 line spaces between the heading and the text.
Underlining a heading is not allowed.
23. The sections of the dissertation and the paragraphs within a section are designated by Arabic numerals throughout the whole dissertation. The introduction and the conclusion are not numbered. A paragraph number consists of the section number and the paragraph number separated by a period. A period is put at the end of the paragraph number, for example "2.3.".
Within each paragraph, items are designated by Arabic numerals. An item number consists of the section, paragraph and item numbers separated by periods. A period is put at the end of the number, for example "1.1.2.".
24. Formulas in the text must be written carefully and clearly. Capital and small letters and superscripts and subscripts must be clearly shown in the formula. The size of characters for formulas is recommended as follows: capital letters and digits 5-6 mm, small letters 3 mm, exponents and indices not less than 2 mm.
The meanings of the symbols are given directly below the formula in the order in which they appear in the formula. The meaning of each symbol should be given on a new line. The first line of the meanings given begins with the word "where" without a colon.
Equations and formulas are separated from the text by blank lines. At least one line must be left above and below each formula. If an equation does not fit on one line, the part that does not fit is carried over after the equals sign (=) or after the signs of addition (+), subtraction (-), multiplication (×) or division (:).
Formulas in the dissertation (if there is more than one) are numbered with Arabic numerals within a section. The formula number consists of the section number and the serial number of the formula in the section, separated by a period. It is shown in parentheses on the right side of the page on the same line as the formula (see Appendix 4).
25. Tables, drawings, diagrams, charts, graphs and photographs in the text of the dissertation and in the appendix must be made on a standard A4 sheet or glued onto standard-size white paper. Explanations and captions to photographs and pictures must be placed so that they are convenient to read.
26. Illustrations (pictures) must be placed so that they are convenient to view. If the dissertation has to be turned in order to view a picture, it should be placed so that it is viewed by turning clockwise. A picture must have a title. Where necessary, explanatory data — an explanatory caption (text under the picture) — are added to pictures. The title of a picture is placed above it and the explanatory data below the picture.
All pictures (graphs, drawings, diagrams, photographs) are designated by the word "figure" and consecutive Arabic numerals by section. Pictures given in the appendices are an exception. The figure number consists of the section number and the figure number separated by a period, for example "Fig. 1.2", and is written below the explanatory caption.
27. Numerical material must be presented in the form of tables. A sample table layout is shown in Appendix 5.
Each table must have a heading. The heading begins with a capital letter. The heading is not underlined.
The headings of table columns begin with capital letters, and the subheadings with small letters if they form one sentence with the heading, or with capital letters if they are independent. The table head must not be divided diagonally. It is recommended that the row height be not less than 8 mm.
A table with many columns may be divided into parts and one part placed under another.
Tables within sections are designated by consecutive Arabic numerals. The table number consists of the section number and the serial number of the table, separated by a period. For example: "Table 1.2".
If the dissertation has one table, it is not numbered and the word "table" is not written.
When part of a table is carried over to another page, the word "table" and its serial number are shown once above the first part of the table, and the word "continued" is written above the remaining parts.
28. References to sources in the text must be given as the serial number of the source in the "List of references used" in square brackets, or provided in footnotes.
References to illustrations are given by the serial number of the figure, for example "Fig. 1.2". References to formulas are given by the serial number of the formula in parentheses, for example "…in formula (2.2)". The text must refer to all tables.
29. Each appendix begins on a new page with the word "Appendix" in the upper right corner. If the dissertation has more than one appendix, they are designated by consecutive Arabic numerals. For example: "Appendix 1", "Appendix 2", and so on.
When the appendices are prepared separately, the word "APPENDICES" is written in capital letters on the title page under the title of the dissertation topic.
The title page of each copy of the dissertation must bear the signature of the dissertation author.
After the dissertation has been submitted to the council, inaccuracies and errors found in it cannot be corrected. Dissertations prepared carelessly and containing errors may be returned to the applicant with a negative decision.
3. DISSERTATION DEFENSE PROCEDURE
At last the day of the defense has come. All the opponents have arrived. The review has been received. The report has been learned by heart. The members of the specialized council, headed by the chairperson, have gathered in a number sufficient for a quorum, and the council session has begun.
The council session follows a strictly established procedure. It is set out in the regulations on the specialized council. But although the process has its own rules and regulations, the defense resembles an interesting dramatic, even theatrical, performance in which the participants are not only spectators but also actors. And the researcher plays the leading role.
The council session is opened by the chairperson. Relying on the personal file, they inform the council members of the council's competence, announce the defense of the dissertation by the researcher, and name the title of the dissertation, the surnames of the official opponents and the name of the leading organization. Before the session opens, a draft conclusion on the dissertation is distributed to the council members; then the floor is given to the scientific secretary, who gives a brief report on the main content of the documents submitted by the researcher and on their conformity with the established procedure.
The floor is given to the researcher for a report on the results of the dissertation work.
A version of the structure of the report was given earlier. Here we would like to share a few thoughts about the style of the report.
In a scientific report it is important that it be understandable not only in content but also, in both structure and method of presentation, to all council members. The council members are highly qualified scholars and specialists who are keenly sensitive to contradictions and sense when a situation is insufficiently substantiated.
For this it is not necessary to be a specialist in the topic of the dissertation. Therefore the argumentation of the main situation must be clearly based on its own logical laws, in a convincing sequence and without contradictions.
Having summed up the report and the results, thanks are expressed to the council members for their attention.
The most important moment of the defense is the researcher's answers to the questions of the members of the specialized council. It is precisely in this part of the defense that the requirements for an academic degree — the scientific profile and individuality of the person — become apparent. One is required to prepare to answer questions of the most varied kinds and character. There is an opinion that it is hardest to answer a question that seems simple at first sight. This really is so: for example, to such a simple question as "What novelty has been created in your dissertation?", one must give an exact answer that contains no superfluous features and particulars. It is unclear to the researcher what novelty interests the questioner: in general or in a specific section. In such a case it is advisable to clarify the question — this may put the questioner in an awkward position, or the questioner will themselves broaden and clarify the question.
One must know the answer to questions of a general nature: about the truthfulness of the novelty, relevance, usefulness for science and practice, and about the object and subject of the research — and these must be prepared in advance.
The researcher's maturity shows in the answers to questions specific to their work and in all the subtleties relating to the dissertation topic. Show here everything you are capable of. How is this done? Before the defense, carefully read your dissertation and author's abstract once more. Study the history of the problem, the question and the tasks. Recall the surnames of the founders and their achievements, remember the co-authors on the topic of the work, colleagues and opponents, and draw up a plan of promising developments. In a word: the key to success is unceasing work and preparation for the defense. Be attentive and respectful to the council members and, if possible, find out each one's first name and patronymic. If a question is repeated, do not say that you have already answered it; it is better to approach the answer from another side. If the answer does not come at once, say that this is due to nervousness, and answer. Human qualities are noticed by everyone.
After the researcher's answers, the floor is given to the scientific supervisor or adviser, and the conclusion of the institution where the dissertation work was done, or of the enterprise to which the researcher is attached, is announced; the review of the leading organization and the other reviews received on the dissertation and author's abstract are read out.
If there is a sufficient number of positive reviews of the author's abstract or dissertation, the scientific secretary, with the permission of the council members, instead of reading them out, summarizes the shortcomings indicated. Negative reviews are read out in full.
After the reviews have been read, the floor is given to the researcher on the shortcomings indicated in the reviews. The researcher reads out previously prepared answers without additions.
Then the official opponents speak. After the opponents have spoken, the floor is given to the researcher. At the researcher's wish, the answer may be given after each opponent.
Those attending the defense may also take part in the subsequent discussion. Before the speeches there is sometimes a wait, which must be filled. For this the researcher may familiarize some council members with the problems of the dissertation in advance, which will shorten the waiting and not distract from the critical discussion of the results of the work.
When the discussion ends, the researcher is given the closing word. The researcher is expected only to thank those who helped during the defense and in preparing for it.
After the researcher's closing word, a closed vote is held on the question of awarding the academic degree. Voting is done by ballots. If two thirds of the council members present who have the right to vote vote in favor, the specialized council's result on awarding the academic degree is considered positive.
After the protocol of the counting commission has been approved, the draft conclusion of the council is discussed.
If a negative result is obtained on the question of awarding the academic degree, the conclusion is not adopted. The text of the conclusion, indicating the classification features of the dissertation result, is adopted by open simple vote of the council members. After that it is announced to the researcher. With this the council session is considered closed.

